Field Guide

Felling Axe vs Splitting Axe: Head Shape, Weight and Handle

A felling axe cuts across the grain to bring a tree down. A splitting axe drives along the grain to break a round apart. From across the yard they look alike. In the wood they behave nothing alike. Here is how to tell them apart and which one the job in front of you wants.

By the Buffalo Nation Knives teamUpdated November 20266 min read

Ridge Runner Hammered Felling Axe, Rosewood, hand-forged Native American-style axe

The Difference at a Glance

These are typical figures for full size axes, not rules. Makers vary, and so do the people swinging them.

Felling axeSplitting axe
Main jobChopping across the grain: felling, limbing, buckingSplitting rounds along the grain
Head shapeThin bit with slim cheeks that taper slowlyWide wedge with thick or swelled cheeks
EdgeThinner and keenerThicker and blunter
Head weightAbout 3 to 4 lb on a full size axeAbout 3 to 6 lb, with mauls at 6 to 8 lb
HandleAbout 28 to 36 in on a full size axeSimilar, from short hatchets up to about 36 in
Sticks in a round?OftenRarely
Chops a limb?WellBadly

Head Geometry Is the Real Difference

Look down at an axe head from the top, through the eye, and you can see the whole story.

The felling axe head

A felling axe has a fairly narrow bit and cheeks that taper slowly from the edge back toward the eye. That slim profile lets the edge sink deep across the fibers of a trunk. Each pair of swings takes out a chip. Do that in the right places and the tree comes down, ideally where you planned.

The splitting axe head

A splitting axe is a wedge with a handle. The cheeks flare out quickly, often with a swell behind the edge, so once the edge starts a crack the head forces the two halves apart. It does not need to cut deep. It needs to push.

The splitting maul

A maul is the splitting axe’s bigger and less patient cousin. It has a heavy head and a flat sledge face on the back for driving wedges. It is slow and tiring, and it will split almost anything you can stand on a block.

What happens when you swap them

Try to split a knotty round with a felling axe and the thin bit sinks in and sticks. Now you are splitting a round and rescuing an axe at the same time. Try to fell a tree with a splitting axe and the fat head bounces and bruises the wood instead of cutting it. Both will get there eventually. Neither will make you look good doing it.

Kindling Hammered Splitting Hatchet, Rosewood, hand-forged Native American-style hatchet
A wedge shaped splitting head on a short handle. It splits kindling, not cordwood.

Weight and Handle Length

A heavier head does more work per swing and tires you out sooner. The US Forest Service ax manual gives 3 to 3.5 pounds as a good starting weight for a working axe head, and suggests a handle that reaches from the ground to your hip as a starting point for length. For splitting, the same manual suggests a single bit head of 5.75 pounds on a 44 inch handle.

Longer handles add head speed and reach. Shorter handles add control. For felling, a long handle lets you swing through a big trunk from a safe stance. For splitting, a long handle also keeps a glancing blow farther from your feet, which your feet will appreciate.

Double bit axes

A double bit axe has two edges on one head. Woodsmen often kept one edge thin for clean chopping and the other a little thicker for knots and rough work. At heart it is a felling tool. Our Balsam Gap Hammered Double-Bit Axe is a full size double bit pattern, 28 inches overall and listed at 52 oz.

A felling axe stuck in a round means you are splitting wood and rescuing an axe at the same time.

Which Axe for Which Job

  • Felling a standing tree: a felling axe. Or a chainsaw, if you have one and know how to use it. We will not be offended.
  • Limbing a downed tree: a felling axe or a camp axe.
  • Bucking logs to length: a felling axe, or a saw, which is usually faster.
  • Splitting a pile of seasoned rounds: a splitting axe or a maul.
  • Making kindling: a hatchet. Our camp axe vs hatchet guide covers that end of the woodpile.

Where Our Axes Fit

Straight talk. We hand forge trade axes, belt axes, camp axes and hatchets. They are traditional patterns with forged heads and hardwood handles, made one at a time. We do not make production splitting mauls. If you have two cords of oak to split before winter, a plain 6 or 8 pound maul is the right tool, and we will not pretend otherwise.

Here is what we do make that fits this topic:

You can see the rest of the range in axes and hatchets, and the smaller patterns in camp hatchets.

Caring for Either Axe

Keep the edge covered when the axe is not working. Wipe the head dry after use and give it a light coat of oil, since high carbon steel rusts. Store it out of the rain, not leaning in a wet woodpile. Check that the head is tight before every session, because a loose head on a long swing is a bad surprise for everyone nearby. The knife care guide applies to axe heads as well.

One more thing. Do not hammer steel wedges with the back of a hand forged trade or camp axe. The eye was not built for that. Use a maul or a sledge.

Questions and answers

What is the difference between a felling axe and a splitting axe?

A felling axe has a thin bit for cutting across the grain, so it chops deep. A splitting axe has a wide, wedge shaped head that forces wood apart along the grain. One chops and the other splits.

Can you use a felling axe to split wood?

You can on small, straight grained rounds. On bigger or knotty rounds the thin head tends to stick. A splitting axe or a maul does that job with less fuss.

Can you cut down a tree with a splitting axe?

Badly. The thick head does not bite deep, so you work much harder for every chip. Use a felling axe or a saw.

How heavy should a splitting axe be?

Splitting axes commonly carry heads of about 3 to 6 pounds, and mauls about 6 to 8 pounds. Heavier splits more per swing and wears you out sooner. Pick a weight you can swing accurately for an hour.

What length handle is best for a felling axe?

Full size felling axes usually have handles of about 28 to 36 inches. A Forest Service rule of thumb is a handle that reaches from the ground to your hip, then adjust for your height and reach.

Is a maul better than a splitting axe?

For big, knotty or stringy rounds, yes. The heavier head and sledge face power through and can drive wedges. For smaller rounds and a lighter day’s work, a splitting axe is quicker and easier on you.

Pieces that go with this guide: Ridge Runner Hammered Felling Axe, Rosewood, Walnut Mountain Hand-Forged Axe, Hickory, Balsam Gap Hammered Double-Bit Axe, High Knob Mirror Camp Axe, Rosewood and Kindling Hammered Splitting Hatchet, Rosewood.

Keep exploring

Shop the guide

Hand-Forged Axes and Hatchets

Felling, forest, trade and camp axe patterns with hickory, ash, oak and rosewood handles.

Shop Axes & Hatchets
  • Humpback Rocks Carving Axe, White Oak: carving axe head with a long straight edge in hammer-marked dark forged steel on a tan white oak with open grain handle with a band of turquoise and white glass beads, a fringed buckskin drop and one peacock feather hanging from the handle
    New
    AX-1054Axes & Hatchets4.4(13)

    Humpback Rocks Carving Axe, White Oak

    4.25 in blade · White oak

    Carving Axe with a carving axe head with a long straight edge and a single bevel, hand-forged in high-carbon steel, on white oak.

    $265.00Free US shipping
  • Charlies Bunion Bearded Hatchet, Black Cherry: bearded hatchet head with a long downward-hooked bit in dark gray acid-etched forged steel on a warm red-brown black cherry wood handle with a band of red and blue glass beads wrapped below the head
    New
    AX-1053Camp Hatchets4.9(22)

    Charlies Bunion Bearded Hatchet, Black Cherry

    4.25 in blade · Cherry

    Bearded Hatchet with a bearded hatchet head with a long hooked bit, hand-forged in high-carbon steel, on black cherry.

    $250.00Free US shipping
  • Harper Creek Camp Hatchet, White Oak: compact hatchet head in dark gray acid-etched forged steel on a tan white oak with open grain handle with a long tan fringed buckskin drop hanging from the grip
    New
    AX-1052Camp Hatchets4.9(14)

    Harper Creek Camp Hatchet, White Oak

    3.75 in blade · White oak

    Camp Hatchet with a camp hatchet head with a convex bit, hand-forged in high-carbon steel, on white oak.

    $215.00Free US shipping
  • Wesser Belt Axe, White Oak: small belt axe head in hammer-marked dark forged steel on a tan white oak with open grain handle with rows of brass tacks, a buckskin grip wrap and two gray pigeon feathers hanging from the handle
    New
    AX-1051Axes & Hatchets4.8(28)

    Wesser Belt Axe, White Oak

    3.25 in blade · White oak

    Belt Axe with a small belt axe head with a flat poll, hand-forged in high-carbon steel, on white oak.

    $210.00Free US shipping

Keep Reading