- Hand-forged
- New
- Free US shipping
- 10% off with OSIYO10
Model DG-428
Beech Creek Toothpick Dagger, White Ash
$430.00
Free US shippingᎣᏏᏲ Osiyo, hello and welcome
Take 10% off your first order with code OSIYO10
Your price with code: $387.00
One use per customer. Enter the code at checkout.
Toothpick Dagger with a 9.5 in hand-forged blade, white ash scales and a fringed leather sheath. An Arkansas toothpick knife: a long, straight double-edged dagger.
- Overall length14.5 in
- Blade length9.5 in
- HandleWhite ash slab scales
- SheathBrown leather sheath with buckskin fringe…
In stock. Ships in 1 to 3 business days.
Outside the US? Flat $39 shipping to Canada and Mexico, $59 to the rest of the world. Shipping and returns
Secure, encrypted SSL checkout
- VISA
- Mastercard
- AMEX
- Discover
- Free US shippingOn every order, no minimum
- 30-day returnsUnused items, easy process
- Limited lifetime warrantyAgainst defects in workmanship
- Hand-forgedForged and finished by hand
- Cherokee-ownedNative American-owned business
- Secure checkoutEncrypted SSL payments
Know your piece
Specifications, care and our policies, all in one place.
Description
We forge the Beech Creek as a toothpick dagger in the old working style: a 9.5 in long narrow toothpick blade in high-carbon steel with a hammered forge finish. White ash scales are pinned to the full tang with brass. It rides in a brown leather sheath with buckskin fringe along the seam, finished with buckskin fringe along the seam. This Native American-style piece is designed by a Cherokee-owned brand and hand-finished in our shop.
Details
- A 9.5 in long narrow toothpick blade, 14.5 in overall.
- White ash scales are pinned to the full tang with brass.
- Buckskin fringe along the seam.
Built for the display case
A slender, dramatic blade for collectors of nineteenth-century patterns.
Care
Dry the steel after use and keep a light coat of oil on it, since high-carbon steel rusts if it is put away damp. Rub boiled linseed oil into the ash once a season. Keep beadwork, fringe and feathers dry and out of direct sun, and brush dust away with a soft dry brush. For long storage keep it out of its leather, in a dry place.
In the box
The Beech Creek toothpick dagger and its brown leather sheath with buckskin fringe along the seam, with buckskin fringe along the seam. Free US shipping and our limited lifetime warranty are included.
Specifications
| Model | DG-428 |
|---|---|
| Overall length | 14.5 in |
| Blade length | 9.5 in |
| Handle length | 5 in |
| Weight | 11.0 oz |
| Blade | Long narrow toothpick blade, hand-forged high-carbon steel, hammered forge finish |
| Handle | White ash slab scales, full tang, brass pins |
| Sheath | Brown leather sheath with buckskin fringe along the seam |
| Decoration | Buckskin fringe along the seam |
| In the box | Knife, brown leather sheath |
Measurements are approximate. Each piece is forged and finished by hand, so hammer marks, horn grain and resin patterns vary slightly from the photos.
Care and use
- Keep it dry. Wipe the blade clean after every use and dry it completely. For food or game, wash with warm soapy water. Never use the dishwasher or leave steel to soak.
- Oil the steel. Wipe on a thin coat of mineral oil or knife oil every few weeks and before storage. Hammered finishes hold moisture in the dimples, so oil those well.
- Wood handle. Wipe with linseed or furniture oil once or twice a year so the wood does not dry out, and never leave it soaking or near a stove.
- Sheath. Leather holds moisture, so never store a damp blade in its sheath, and keep the piece out of the sheath for long-term storage. Condition the leather once or twice a year. Keep beads, fringe and feathers dry and out of strong sun, and dust them with a soft brush.
- Sharpening. Use a whetstone or a guided sharpener at about 20 degrees per side, coarse to fine grit, then strop on leather. Avoid powered grinders, which can overheat the edge.
- Use it for its job. A knife is not a pry bar or a screwdriver.
Shipping and returns
- Free US shipping on every order, with no minimum.
- Ships in 1 to 3 business days. Tracking is emailed when your order ships. Every knife and tomahawk ships in its sheath and protective packaging.
- International: a flat $39 per order to Canada and Mexico and $59 per order to the rest of the world. You are responsible for import duties, taxes and local restrictions. Some countries limit the import of knives, so please check before ordering. We may cancel and refund orders to places where we cannot legally ship.
- 30-day returns. Return an item within 30 days of delivery if it is unused, unsharpened and in its original packaging with the sheath. Return shipping is paid by the buyer unless the item arrived damaged or defective. Refunds go to the original payment method within 7 business days of receiving the return.
- Engraving is final sale. Items that have been used, sharpened, engraved or customized cannot be returned.
- Damaged or wrong item? Email us within 7 days of delivery with photos. We pay return shipping and send a replacement or a full refund, your choice.
- Adults 18 and over only. Please check your state and local knife laws before ordering.
Limited lifetime warranty
Every Buffalo Nation knife and tomahawk is covered against defects in materials and workmanship for the lifetime of the original buyer. If a blade cracks, a handle separates or a pivot fails without misuse, we repair it or, if repair is not possible, replace it with the same or a comparable model.
- Not covered: misuse such as prying, batoning, throwing or striking metal or stone; normal wear such as dulling, scratches, sheath wear and the natural aging of horn, wood and leather; rust from wet storage; damage from sharpening, grinding or modification; lost items; and beads or feathers that wear over time.
- To make a claim, email sales@buffalonationknives.com with your order number, a short description and clear photos. We usually reply within two business days, and approved repairs and replacements come back to you at no charge.

Cherokee-ownedᏣᎳᎩ Tsalagi
About the maker
Buffalo Nation Knives is a Cherokee-owned, Native American-owned shop in Rockwood, Tennessee. Our founder, Russ Rogers, has been making knives since 2005.
Some of our pieces are forged by Russ and our small team. Many come from small handmade makers we work with. Every piece is finished by hand in our shop: the beadwork, feathers, fringe and sheath work, then a final edge and inspection. Because each one is made and finished by hand, no two are exactly alike.
Being Native-owned does not make a product Native-made, so we describe each piece plainly: the steel, the handle and how it was finished. Ask us about any piece and we will tell you how it was made.
Russ RogersFounder, Buffalo Nation KnivesCherokee · making knives since 2005
Who made this piece: Forged in our Rockwood shop or by one of the small handmade makers we work with, then finished by hand here: beadwork, feathers, fringe, final edge and inspection.
From fire to your hands
Every piece starts as raw steel and ends as a tool you can trust.
01Forge
Steel is heated until it glows and shaped with hammer and anvil. On hammered blades, those marks stay as the finish.
02Handle and fit
Buffalo horn, rosewood or resin is fitted, pinned and shaped so the handle sits right in your grip.
03Finish and inspect
The edge is sharpened and checked, the sheath is fitted, and the piece is packed in its sheath and protective packaging.
Where each step happens depends on the piece. Ask us and we will tell you exactly how yours was made.
In our customers' hands
Reviews from our customers, published whether they are positive or negative.
Rated 4.9 out of 5. Based on 28 reviews
Reviews come from real customers and are published whether they are positive or negative. We never pay for reviews or edit what customers write.
Ask about this piece
Not sure about size, materials or shipping to your area? Ask us. A real person answers, usually within one business day.
Ask a questionCommon questions, answered by our shop
How soon will it ship?
In-stock pieces ship in 1 to 3 business days. Shipping is free to any US address, and tracking is emailed when your order ships.
Can I add engraving?
Yes. Use the engraving option above to add up to 15 characters, spaces included, for $20. We laser engrave the blade or handle, choosing the spot that reads best. Engraved items are final sale.
Can I return it?
Yes, within 30 days of delivery if it is unused, unsharpened and in its original packaging with the sheath. Engraved, used or sharpened items cannot be returned.
Is it legal where I live?
Knife laws vary by state, city and country. We sell only to adults 18 and over, and buyers are responsible for knowing the laws where they live and carry.
Customer questions about this piece
What is this dagger made for?
It is built for the display case. A slender, dramatic blade for collectors of nineteenth-century patterns.
Is this dagger full tang?
Yes, it is full tang. White ash scales are pinned to the full tang with brass.
Is the blade stainless or carbon steel?
High-carbon steel, not stainless. The blade is hand-forged high-carbon steel, hammered forge finish. Dry the steel after use and keep a light coat of oil on it, since high-carbon steel rusts if it is put away damp.
Does it come with a sheath?
Yes. It comes with a brown leather sheath with buckskin fringe along the seam.
More from these collections
This piece belongs to
- Daggers 52 pieces
- Native American-Style Knives 492 pieces
Related collections
- Bowie Knives 58 pieces
- Ring Pommel Knives 38 pieces
- Spears & Lances 12 pieces
- War Clubs 14 pieces
- Neck Knives & Small Fixed Blades 65 pieces























28 reviews for Beech Creek Toothpick Dagger, White Ash
Love it
I was nervous ordering something like this online but it is the real thing. Would buy again.
BBrenda J., SDNovember 2026
Gift was a hit
My husband collects these and said this is one of the nicest he owns. Thank you.
KKatherine T., MONovember 2026
Great piece
Sits on my mantel most of the year and comes out for hunting season.
JJames Y., SCSeptember 2026
Could not be happier
Showed it to the guys at deer camp and two of them asked where I got it.
JJeffrey C., GASeptember 2026
Heirloom quality
Feels balanced in the hand and the white ash has a nice warm grip.
AAmanda M., MOSeptember 2026
Love it
The white ash looks even better in person and the fit and finish are clean. Shipping took five days.
AAshley E., MOAugust 2026
Exactly what I hoped for
Sits on my mantel most of the year and comes out for hunting season. Would buy again.
WWilliam M., NCAugust 2026
Happy with it
Quality is there. The color of the white ash is a bit darker than the photo, which I do not mind. Still recommend it.
MMatthew K., OKAugust 2026
Top notch
You can tell it was finished by hand. No gaps, no rough spots, and it came with a good edge. Shipping took five days.
MMary C., NHAugust 2026
Worth every dollar
Feels balanced in the hand and the white ash has a nice warm grip. Thank you.
TTammy Y., WYAugust 2026
Five stars
You can tell it was finished by hand. No gaps, no rough spots, and it came with a good edge. Shipping took five days.
JJudy Y., IDJuly 2026
Worth every dollar
Packaging was careful and it showed up two days early.
RRebecca P., IDJune 2026
Five stars
Showed it to the guys at deer camp and two of them asked where I got it. The leather smells great and fits snug.
RRachel M., KSMarch 2026
Solid and handsome
Arrived sharp and well packed. The blade has real heft and the grind is even.
LLisa V., ORFebruary 2026
Very impressed
Sits on my mantel most of the year and comes out for hunting season. The leather smells great and fits snug.
RRobert F., NVDecember 2025
Heirloom quality
I was nervous ordering something like this online but it is the real thing. Already looking at another one.
BBenjamin S., COOctober 2025
Worth every dollar
Took an edge easily and has kept it through a lot of use.
JJacob H., NEOctober 2025
Gift was a hit
Bought it as a gift and he has not put it down since. Would buy again.
LLarry B., VTJune 2025
Five stars
Heavier and better made than the ones I have seen at shows for twice the money. Thank you.
JJustin P., WYJune 2025
Very impressed
Used it all weekend at camp and it held up the whole time. Highly recommend.
KKevin F., SCMay 2025
Very impressed
Third piece I have bought here and the quality has been the same every time. Thank you.
BBetty M., CAApril 2025
Exactly what I hoped for
The white ash looks even better in person and the fit and finish are clean. The leather smells great and fits snug.
SSandra L., LAMarch 2025
Worth every dollar
The white ash looks even better in person and the fit and finish are clean.
JJoseph K., AKMarch 2025
Good value
Very happy with it. I would have liked a little more detail in the photos about the size. Still recommend it.
DDiane P., OHMarch 2025
Five stars
Packaging was careful and it showed up two days early.
MMichael N., VTFebruary 2025
Solid, not perfect
Looks great on the shelf. Slightly heavier than I expected from the listing. Still recommend it.
SSteven V., WIJanuary 2025
Real craftsmanship
The forge finish on the blade has a lot of character. No two would look alike. Thank you.
MMary B., ALDecember 2024
Love it
Used it all weekend at camp and it held up the whole time.
DDeborah E., VADecember 2024
Showing 6 of 28 reviews